You say tomato, I say to-WHOA, Nellie.


I would have invited you over for dinner, but I couldn’t find your phone number anywhere, I SWEAR.

I’m a little sad tonight, because I’ve just learned that I’ve wasted 30 years of my life not eating delicious, delicious tomatoes.

You see, I always thought I didn’t like tomatoes. Tomato sauce, sure (as long as there are no visible tomato chunks), tomato soup, okay, tomato ketchup, acceptable. But a whole, raw tomato? No, thank you, I’ll pass.

You can imagine how much this endeared me to my mother and nonna and zias.

As it turns out, I DO like tomatoes. A lot. What I DON’T like are the mealy, soulless, pale pink simulacra of tomatoes generally available in the standard American supermarket.

I didn’t know. Dear lord, I DIDN’T KNOW.


I’m like the fucking jolly green giant and Mother Nature all rolled into one.

These tomatoes and herbs grew merrily in my garden with minimal assistance from me. I didn’t stake them, didn’t cage them when they flopped, let invasive vines clamber over them and spent most of their young lives trying not to be insane. Frankly, I only planted them because that’s what you’re supposed to do in a New Jersey backyard; I didn’t really plan ahead for dealing with the actual fruits themselves, I think I assumed that I’d kill the plants before they ever got to the fruiting stage. And yet, such was their tenacity they grew despite my utter neglect, dozens and dozens of them grew. And more dozens. An overwhelming number of tomatoes for someone who doesn’t like tomatoes married to someone else who doesn’t like tomatoes. It brings a tear to my jaundiced eye.

Along with the backyard bounty, we’re members of a CSA. Which means: MORE TOMATOES.

It was time to confront the tomatoes head on.* We would learn to like them or die give up and order Chinese take-out trying. So I planned an entire dinner showcasing the tomato: classic caprese salad, a basic panzanella, and tomato and goat cheese tartlets.

*Tomatoes! Apply directly to the forehead.**

**Sorry, I just had to.


A rare glimpse at the often-invoked “hot buttered ass.”

I mean, come on. It looks like a little heiny, doesn’t it?

Before dealing with the tomatoes, I had to deal with the mozzarella. I had a hunk of fresh mozzarella leftover from the last batch of grilled pizza, but because of a massive brain fart had neglected to store it in liquid.

Luckily, Serious Eats informed me that it is possible to revive rubbery, refrigerated mozzarella by gently poaching the cold cheese in warm, whole milk. It’s still not the same as fresh, but it definitely re-hydrates and reinvigorates tired cheese and helps to play up its milky sweetness. The only caveat: flip the mozzarella periodically so the side touching the warm pot doesn’t start to melt and spread.


Am I really going to be able to eat this? In the words of New Jersey bard Jon Bon Jovi, I’m livin’ on a prayer.

While the cheese visited the spa, I threw the panzanella together so it would have time to sit and meld and the bread to soften. For those who don’t know, panzanella is a traditional Tuscan peasant dish created to use up day(s)-old bread. At its most basic, cubes of bread are tossed with fresh tomato, herbs, olive oil and red wine vinegar; common additions include onion and olives.

Since I hadn’t really planned ahead I didn’t have any day-old bread on hand, but I figured shitty Pathmark “Italian” bread briefly dried out in the oven would approximate it. Some recipes call for soaking the bread in water or toasting it in the oven, but I don’t like the texture either of those methods produce – I wanted the bread to retain some chew (so soaking was out) but not crunch (ditto toasting) (I get a little Goldilocks about shit like this).

Otherwise, I kept my salad super simple: bread, tomatoes, basil, red onion, freshly ground pepper, sea salt, olive oil and vinegar. I mixed everything together and set the bowl aside, tossing it every 5 minutes or whenever I remembered.


We’ll all live happily ever after on the big goat cheese mountain.

Okay, I could lie to you about this next part, but I have too much respect for you. The basic idea of the tarts – tomato, cheese, puff pastry – came from Paula Deen. And I don’t mean my neighbor who happens to be named Paula Deen and is a really good cook, I mean the actual Paula Deen, the one sculpted from an enormous slab of cream cheese who has that show on the food network where she forces c-list celebrities to deep-fry lasagna to try and bolster their popularity among the “thinks Hungry Man dinners are a special treat” demographic.

I don’t remember what kind of cheese she uses, most likely Velveeta Brand Cheese-Like Food Product, but I decided to go with herbed goat cheese. Since my herb garden is also pretty prolific, I bought a small log of fresh, young goat cheese and mixed in fresh chives, thyme and black pepper.


I am a winner by association!

Do you have this in your freezer? You should. It’s the only puff pastry explicitly endorsed by Details magazine!

Seriously, Dufour puff pastry is no joke. Awesome quick tarts, easy pot pie topping, buttery and perfect – I’m pretty sure you could wrap a car tire in this stuff and bake it off, and I would eat it. And probably ask for seconds. They are not paying me to say any of this, although if anyone from Dufour is reading this and would like to pay me, I would be happy to continue extolling the virtues of your award-winning, stunningly flaky puff pastry.


Tried a piece of the tomato-y bread…slowly warming to the idea.

Remembered to toss the panzanella.


This one HAS to be good.

I trimmed the puff pastry into rectangle and layered each sheet with slices of ruby-red, juicy plum tomato. I sprinkled dabs of the goat cheese and some smoked grey salt over the top, added a wee drizzle of olive oil and popped them into the oven. The pastry trimmings went in as well; treats for the cook, dontcha know.

My oven has a convection setting that I almost never use because I’m not quite sure exactly what it does or what temperature adjustments I should make when using it, and I’m highly risk-averse. Since I was already throwing caution to the wind with this tomato-fest, I decided to live in the fast lane and flipped it on* hoping it would help cope with any liquid given off by the tomatoes and leave me with a crisp tart with deep tomato flavor.

*Seriously, this is what passes for exciting around here.


At the very least, pork – in the form of sweet sopressata – will save the day.

The tarts baked, the panzanella sat, and I sliced up my reanimated cheese and some colorful CSA tomatoes and threw together the caprese with some backyard basil.


Mood: Cautiously Optimistic

The tarts started to smell really fricking good. True, some of this was due to the puff pastry, which can’t not smell good. But an amazingly sweet, heady tomato smell was wafting out as well.

I gave them a few more minutes under the broiler to get some golden color on the cheese and give the tomatoes one last blast of high heat, and dinner was served. I made myself a plate that, while perhaps of questionable tastiness was at least visually gorgeous, representative of everything that’s good about summer excepting watermelon and Choco Tacos.


I WILL NEVER DOUBT AGAIN. But you still can’t make me eat an olive.*

Three tomato preparations, three different flavor sensations, three dishes centered on tomatoes that I really, really like. Do you know how to tell just how much I liked the tomato dishes? I DID NOT FINISH THE PORK PRODUCTS ON THE PLATE.

I know, right?

Caprese salad, I finally get you now. The sweet acidity of the tomatoes, the gentle milkiness of the cheese, the fresh lemony bite of basil, all with a hint of salt and bare drizzle of olive oil: there is a reason this is a classic. The tomato-soaked bread paired with sweet roma tomatoes, sweetly punchy red onion and a hint of vinegar? Italian peasants know where it is at.

Tomato tart? Holy shitballs, y’all. You know what, I’ll kick it up a notch: holy FUCKING shitballs. Little baby Jesus, Mary, Joseph and all the saints, the transformation that happens when you roast high quality, fresh, flavorful tomatoes and concentrate their flavor is out of this goddamned world. The puff pastry was a mere vehicle for these priceless gems, it’s buttery goodness utterly forgotten. It was like the fucking rapture, me and these tomatoes. No single thing that I’ve eaten in the U.S. has ever made me as homesick for Italy as these damn tomatoes. What am I going to do when tomato season is over? HOW WILL I LIVE?

OH. MY. GOD.

FYI, I’m not writing out recipes for any of these things, because (1) a caprese salad is just things stacked on other things, (2) there are a thousand recipes for panzanella that will lead you to a tasty result, and you’ll just end up making it up as you go along anyway, and (3) the tart only has the 5 ingredients mentioned (puff pastry, tomatoes, goat cheese, good salt, olive oil).

*Yes, yes, what’s wrong with me, olives are delicious, I’m crazy, I know, I know. I’m still not eating one.

0 thoughts on “You say tomato, I say to-WHOA, Nellie.

  1. I LOVE tomatoes! Welcome to the club. The classic BLT OH-only enjoyed with a high quality , ripe tomato. Yeah- I watch them ripen on the vine….waiting. That’s the flavor of summer.

  2. Ohhhh Michelle. I just discovered these very same flavors this year. I didn’t know either, seriously. For the last two months, I have been astounded by tomatoes. Who knew?

    That first picture just kills me. Making something tomorrow…

  3. Sounds like you’ve developed a fatal attraction to your tomatoes :) Well, I wouldn’t blame you. This post, appropriately censored, should be given to all toddlers to properly orient them to the glory of tomatoes.

    By the way, with the simple substitution of goat cheese, you’ve already elevated yourself skyscrapers over Paula Deen. Let’s not forget the casserole you made before, okay? :P

    What’s wrong with you? Olives are delicious. You’re crazy. :P

  4. yeah, those round greenish red tomato like things in the grocery stores do tend to be flavourless. however, roma tomatoes, if you get them slightly green and then let them ripen on your table/countertop will get some flavour to them. then there are the expensive ones that they sell still attached to the vine…they’re good too but nothing on earth beats the smell, aroma and taste of a home grown tomato.

    oh, when you find you’re bringing in more than you can eat raw (ad if you have more than 2 plants this will probably be true) you can just stick them into a bag and freeze them in their skins. when it’s time to make a sauce/chili/soup, just take out what you’re going to use, dump them in a sink of hot water and peel the skins off. they’ll thaw in dish you’re cooking and can be cut up after they’ve stewed a bit. it’ll bring the summer taste of your garden back to you in mid winter.

    also, when you have to do the last harvest before the freeze ad you have a pile of green ones, don’t put them on your window sill. put them in a box and layer them, one tomato thick between newspaper and check them daily. they’ll ripen much better and won’t rot. if there are a few stubborn ones that won’t ripen, put an apple in with them. the apple emits a gas that makes a tomato get ripe (at least that’s what bran says and he knows tomatoes).

    i’m glad you’re in the tomato leagues. now all we have to do is to get you to eat olives. the black giants (in brine) are really good with bacon and eggs.

  5. I love olives… but only since last year or so…

    I’ve always liked tomatoes… but only cuz dad grew his own – supermarket tomatoes aren’t worth the vines they’re grown on…

    Whatever, your post made me laugh, and at this time of the morning, qudos to you!

  6. I can’t believe you tomatoes were unstaked and unprotected and the critters didn’t get them all. Here in South Jersey we are going to some pretty ridiculous lengths to keep the squirrels, chipmunks and rabbits from our tomatoes.

    Anyway, your dinner looks fabulous. I’m going to try one of those tarts with my ABUNDANCE of tomatoes.

    Next year, you might consider growing Rutgers (Ramopo) tomatoes. They are the true “jersey” tomato and are huge and flavorful and the most beautiful color red. You will have to stake these suckers though. Here’s a link to some info:

    http://njfarmfresh.rutgers.edu/JerseyTomato.html

    You will not be sorry you grew them.

  7. What is Wrong with you? Olives are delicious, You are Crazy!

    (someone had to say it, but really it’s only true of the little green ones with pimentos in them….ok ok, it’s also true of the big green ones with blue cheese stuffed in them…what? what about the bacon&cream cheese stuffed olives? oh all right. .. .shut up, shut up, make the voices in my head shut up…)

  8. AMEN!!! I have so many tomatoes I’m losing my damn mind here (and canning like a crazy lady), and I really, really want to make those tomato tarts. I have to wait until my MiL isn’t home for dinner though–she can’t eat wheat. This puts a serious crimp in my cooking plans sometimes . . .

    But I’m glad you’ve come around to the tomato way of life. Though it is sad when summer is over, because then you just can’t eat tomatoes from the store, which means you just don’t eat tomatoes AT ALL for 8 months. It’s tragic.

  9. I lurve tomatoes. But I also adore olives. Not just any olives. I could leave the green ones (and anything in a CAN) but the garlic stuffed kalamata olives from a well stocked and maintained olive bar? I would commit harm for those! (And the bleu cheese ones and the bacon and cream cheese ones.)

  10. jody, i didn’t even think of that. i must have a blt, immediately. or for dinner tomorrow. we got a huge, gorgeous heirloom with yesterday’s CSA veggies that is a perfect candidate.

    js, yes! wet rags! i’m not totally sure how you know what they taste like, but it seems accurate.

    robin, i can’t believe it either – we have a TON of squirrels. next year i definitely want to try and grow more kinds; i don’t have that much room, but i could probably swing 4 different varieties.

  11. Wow, this looks like an amazing dinner (besides the meat, of course) that I’d actually make! (Please see my blog for the irony.) And olives? Blech.

  12. I do feel your pain. It took me quite a few years (more like 20 than 30) to understand what a good tomato was and how it can make up the most divine dishes using the power of its own sweet self.

    What it is about the magical combination of tomatoes and the state of NJ? You can let your tomato plants get totally abused and yet have great tomatoes. I make sure I buy my tomatoes in NJ every weekend. No other state grows tomatoes quite so miraculously (although I did experience some miraculous tomatoes in London earlier this year- how do you get such wonderful tomatoes in March?)

    You’ve invented a new type of cheese: Butt Mozzarella. Mozzarella Al Cullo (I would love to hear Giada say that)

  13. That is one AWESOME freaking spread.

    And….Ok, holy shit! You didn’t like tomatoes? Really? Garden tomatoes? And don’t diss the olive until you’ve tried one from Spain. Let me send you a sample of THEE best on the planet…seriously….I hated olives until I tried these. In fact? I hated olives *and* anchovies. Now both are part of my everyday vocabulary.

  14. During the days of my childhood, I would come home from school, grab a whole tomato out of the fridge, grab the salt shaker, and eat the tomato like an apple! I thought that it was the best snack in the world! Now, as I lightly push the big 4-0, I found that I’ve traded my old tomato snack for pints of Ben & Jerry’s. Good times!

  15. OMG. Welcome to the world of tomatoes the way they nature intended, not the bioengineered store-bought picked-too-early crap they try to pass off as something genetically similar to a tomato at the grocery store (sometimes even Whole Foods, although admittedly, they have problems more in winter). Wait until you lovingly combine a real tomato with real BACON, a bit of real lettuce (i.e., iceberg isn’t lettuce), and a dash of salt and pepper on good bread to make a BLT. You may just cream yourself…

  16. Did Brian like them?
    I think a plain, ripe, fresh tomato with olive oil and a sprinkle of salt is pretty much the best thing you can eat in the summer and even I can’t mess it up.

  17. rachel, i don’t know, but i’m not complaining.

    canary, i never HAD a garden tomato, because my first experience of raw tomato was shitty supermarket tomato. i’m not to blame, i tell you.

    jodi, he LOVED them. we are both total tomato converts.

  18. Pingback: thursday night smackdown » Blog Archive » Thursday Night Smackdown: Hurry, man, before there’s still time.

  19. Another convert! I just wish our garden did as well this year as the last. Too much rain=not enough tomatoes. Damn!!

    Freaking gorgeous food, Michelle!

  20. this cracks me up cause i am the same exact way with tomatoes, sauce and the like (ew! i hate the chunks). I keep wanting to try them again cause man, everything with tomatoes looks so damn good. but i can’t bring myself to it. i just can’t.

    and now you have gone and done it and loved it, it gives me hope.
    /wipe tears from my eyes

  21. “It’s My Life” by Bon Jovi was playing in my other browser window when I read the caption about the New Jersey bard. How is that for stars aligning? :)

    This whole meal looks amazing. Yum!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s